NME’s Top 500: A “repeat” of ‘Rolling Stone’ in 2003

Today, in the Bailleau Library, I had a look at “best albums” lists on a special scholarly site and saw that British magazine New Musical Express had only a few months ago written their own “Top 500”. The identity of its top album, which I have seen strongly praised and aggressively criticised (citing the Warlock Pinchers “Morrissey Rides a ****Horse” in the latter case), was enough to make me have a look, and here is the full list, with albums I own highlighted in pink.

#	Album	Artist	Harrington’s List	Keenan’s List
1	The Queen Is Dead	The Smiths	N	Y
2	Revolver	The Beatles	N	N(Y)
3	Hunky Dory	David Bowie	N(Y)	N
4	Is This It	The Strokes	N	N
5	The Velvet Underground and Nico	The Velvet Underground	Y	Y
6	Different Class	Pulp	N	N
7	The Stone Roses	The Stone Roses	N	N
8	Doolittle	Pixies	N	N
9	The Beatles	The Beatles	N	Y
10	Definitely Maybe	Oasis	N	N
11	Nevermind	Nirvana	N(Y)	N
12	Horses	Patti Smith	Y	N(Y)
13	Funeral	Arcade Fire
14	Low	David Bowie	N(Y)	N
15	Let England Shake	PJ Harvey	N	N
16	Closer	Joy Division	Y	N
17	It Takes a Nation of Millions To Hold Us Back	Public Enemy	Y	N(Y)
18	Loveless	My Bloody Valentine	N	N
19	Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not	Arctic Monkeys
20	OK Computer	Radiohead	N	N
21	My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy	Kanye West
22	Parklife	Blur	N	N
23	The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars	David Bowie	N(Y)	N
24	Exile on Main Street	The Rolling Stones	N(Y)	N(Y)
25	What’s Going On	Marvin Gaye	N	N
26	Pet Sounds	The Beach Boys	Y	N(Y)
27	Screamadelica	Primal Scream	N	N
28	Back to Black	Amy Winehouse
29	Marquee Moon	Television	Y	N(Y)
30	Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers)	Wu-Tang Clan	N	N
31	Dog Man Star	Suede	N	N
32	Paul’s Boutique	Beastie Boys	N	N
33	Modern Life Is Rubbish	Blur	N	N
34	Abbey Road	The Beatles	N	N(Y)
35	In Utero	Nirvana	N(Y)	N
36	Blood on the Tracks	Bob Dylan	N	N(Y)
37	Forever Changes	Love	Y	N
38	Never Mind the Bollocks… Here’s the Sex Pistols	Sex Pistols	Y	N
39	London Calling	The Clash	N(Y)	N
40	Unknown Pleasure	Joy Division	N(Y)	N
41	Daydream Nation	Sonic Youth	Y	N(Y)
42	Innervisions	Stevie Wonder	N	N
43	Rubber Soul	The Beatles	N	N(Y)
44	The Holy Bible	Manic Street Preachers	N	N
45	Parallel Lines	Blondie	N	N
46	Debut	Björk	N	N
47	Strangeways, Here We Come	The Smiths	N	N(Y)
48	Hounds of Love	Kate Bush	N	Y
49	Sound of Silver	LCD Soundsystem
50	Dusty in Memphis	Dusty Springfield	N	Y
51	Rumours	Fleetwood Mac	N	N
52	Let It Bleed	The Rolling Stones	N(Y)	N(Y)
53	Station to Station	David Bowie	N(Y)	N
54	Remain in Light	Talking Heads	N	N
55	Sticky Fingers	The Rolling Stones	N(Y)	N(Y)
56	After the Gold Rush	Neil Young	N(Y)	N(Y)
57	The Man Machine	Kraftwerk	N	N
58	Surfer Rosa	Pixies	N	N
59	In Rainbows	Radiohead	N	N
60	Blue Lines	Massive Attack	N	N
61	The Clash	The Clash	Y	N
62	Blonde on Blonde	Bob Dylan	N	N(Y)
63	Blue	Joni Mitchell	N	N
64	Highway 61 Revisited	Bob Dylan	N	N(Y)
65	Automatic For the People	R.E.M.	N	N(Y)
66	The Bends	Radiohead	N	N
67	(What’s the Story) Morning Glory	Oasis	N	N
68	Astral Weeks	Van Morrison	N	Y
69	Murmur	R.E.M.	N	N(Y)
70	Up the Bracket	The Libertines	N	N
71	Harvest	Neil Young	N(Y)	N(Y)
72	Transformer	Lou Reed	N	N(Y)
73	Bringing It All Back Home	Bob Dylan	N	N(Y)
74	Illmatic	Nas	N	N
75	Dookie	Green Day	N	N
76	Discovery	Daft Punk	N	N
77	White Blood Cells	The White Stripes
78	Suede	Suede	N	N
79	Kind of Blue	Miles Davis	N(Y)	Y
80	Raw Power	Iggy and the Stooges	N(Y)	N(Y)
81	Trans-Europe Express	Kraftwerk	N	N
82	Tapestry	Carole King	N	N
83	The Band	The Band	N	N(Y)
84	Live Through This	Hole	N	N
85	Born to Run	Bruce Springsteen	N	N(Y)
86	Grace	Jeff Buckley	N	N
87	Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band	The Beatles	N	N(Y)
88	For Your Pleasure	Roxy Music	N(Y)	N
89	The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill	Lauryn Hill	N	N
90	A Grand Don’t Come For Free	The Streets
91	Purple Rain	Prince and the Revolution	N	N
92	Radiator	Super Furry Animals	N	N
93	Songs for the Deaf	Queens of the Stone Age	N	N
94	Beggars Banquet	The Rolling Stones	Y	N(Y)
95	Spirit of Eden	Talk Talk	N	N
96	Fear of a Black Planet	Public Enemy	N(Y)	Y
97	The Smiths	The Smiths	N	N(Y)
98	In the Aeroplane Over the Sea	Neutral Milk Hotel	N	N
99	The Libertines	The Libertines	N	N
100	Hatful of Hollow	The Smiths	N	N(Y)
101	Computer World	Kraftwerk	N	N
102	The Soft Bulletin	The Flaming Lips	N	N
103	Electric Ladyland	The Jimi Hendrix Experience	N(Y)	N(Y)
104	Funhouse	The Stooges	Y	Y
105	Rain Dogs	Tom Waits	N	N
106	IV	Led Zeppelin	N	Y
107	Rage Against the Machine	Rage Against the Machine	N	N
108	Pinkerton	Weezer	N	N
109	Darkness on the Edge of Town	Bruce Springsteen	N	N(Y)
110	Liege and Lief	Fairport Convention	N	Y
111	Dare	The Human League	N	N
112	Liquid Swords	GZA
113	If You’re Feeling Sinister	Belle and Sebastian	N	Y
114	Kid A	Radiohead	N	N
115	Bandwagonesque	Teenage Fanclub	N	N
116	Elephant	The White Stripes	N	N
117	The Lexicon of Love	ABC	N	N
118	Searching for the Young Soul Rebels	Dexys Midnight Runners	N	N
119	His‘N’Hers	Pulp	N	N
120	3 Feet High and Rising	De La Soul	N	N
121	Selected Ambient Works 85-92	Aphex Twin	N	N
122	Technique	New Order	N	N
123	13	Blur	N	N
124	Graceland	Paul Simon	N	N
125	Live at the Apollo	James Brown	N	Y
126	Ill Communication	Beastie Boys	N	N
127	Ramones	Ramones	Y	Y
128	Urban Hymns	The Verve	N	N
129	On the Beach	Neil Young	N(Y)	N(Y)
130	Turn on the Bright Lights	Interpol
131	Thriller	Michael Jackson	N	N
132	Dark Side of the Moon	Pink Floyd	N	N
133	John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band	John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band	N	N
134	Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea	PJ Harvey	N	N
135	The Marshall Mathers LP	Eminem	N	N
136	Fever to Tell	Yeah Yeah Yeahs	N	N
137	Blur	Blur	N	N
138	Illinois	Sufjan Stevens
139	Disintegration	The Cure	N	N
140	Bryter Layter	Nick Drake	N	N
141	Natty Dread	Bob Marley and the Wailers	N	N
142	Histoire de Melody Nelson	Serge Gainsbourg	N	N
143	Desire	Bob Dylan	N	N(Y)
144	Are You Experienced	The Jimi Hendrix Experience	Y	N(Y)
145	Odessey and Oracle	The Zombies	N	Y
146	Relationship of Command	At the Drive-In
147	Channel Orange	Frank Ocean
148	Nebraska	Bruce Springsteen	N	Y
149	Either/Or	Elliot Smith	N	N
150	Original Pirate Material	The Streets
151	Dry	PJ Harvey	N	N
152	Deserter’s Songs	Mercury Rev	N	N
153	The La’s	The La’s	N	N
154	To Bring You My Love	PJ Harvey	N	N
155	Music for the Jilted Generation	The Prodigy	N	N
156	Ladies and Gentlemen We Are Floating in Space	Spiritualized	N	N
157	Psychocandy	The Jesus and Mary Chain	N	N
158	Two Dancers	Wild Beasts
159	Entertainment!	Gang of Four	N	N
160	XTRMTR	Primal Scream	N	N
161	The Suburbs	Arcade Fire
162	The Boxer	The National
163	Neu ‘75!	Neu!	N	Y
164	At Folsom Prison	Johnny Cash	N	N(Y)
165	Let Love In	Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds	N	N(Y)
166	This is Hardcore	Pulp	N	N
167	Lady Soul	Aretha Franklin	N	N
168	Dummy	Portishead	N	N
169	Don’t Stand Me Down	Dexys Midnight Runners	N	N
170	Siamese Dream	Smashing Pumpkins	N	N
171	Fear of Music	Talking Heads	N	N
172	Songs in the Key of Life	Stevie Wonder	N	N
173	III	Led Zeppelin	N	N(Y)
174	I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning	Bright Eyes
175	Young Americans	David Bowie	N(Y)	N
176	Want One	Rufus Wainwright	N	N
177	Young Team	Mogwai	N	N
178	The Coral	The Coral
179	Miss E…So Addictive	Missy Elliott	N	N
180	Germ Free Adolescents	X-Ray Spex	N	N
181	Music Has the Right to Children	Boards of Canada	N	N
182	Everything Must Go	Manic Street Preachers	N	N
183	Speakerboxxx/The Love Below	OutKast	N	N
184	Kala	MIA
185	Paid in Full	Eric B and Rakim	N	N
186	The Blueprint	Jay-Z	N	N
187	Isn’t Anything	My Bloody Valentine	N	N
188	A Love Supreme	John Coltrane	N(Y)	Y
189	A Wizard, A True Star	Todd Rundgren	N	N
190	Piper at the Gates of Dawn	Pink Floyd	N	N
191	Elastica	Elastica	N	N
192	Franz Ferdinand	Franz Ferdinand	N	N
193	Gold	Ryan Adams	N	N
194	Appetite for Destruction	Guns‘N’Roses	N	N
195	A Hard Day’s Night	The Beatles	N	N(Y)
196	Rattus Norvegicus	The Stranglers	N	N
197	Back in Black	AC/DC	N(Y)	Y
198	Sign of the Times	Prince	N	N
199	Giant Steps	The Boo Radleys
200	Last Splash	The Breeders	N	N
201	Hex Enduction Hour	The Fall	N	N
202	Maxinquaye	Tricky	N	N
203	Teen Dream	Beach House
204	Bad	Michael Jackson	N	N
205	Straight Outta Compton	NWA	N	Y
206	Slanted and Enchanted	Pavement	N	N
207	Pearl	Janis Joplin	N	N
208	Risque	Chic	N	N
209	The Kick Inside	Kate Bush	N	N(Y)
210	69 Love Songs	The Magnetic Fields	N	N
211	Nightclubbing	Grace Jones	N	N
212	Youth and Young Manhood	Kings of Leon
213	One Nation under a Groove	Funkadelic	N(Y)	N(Y)
214	Moon Safari	Air	N	N
215	Mezzanine	Massive Attack	N	N
216	Power, Corrruption and Lies	New Order	N	N
217	Lust for Life	Iggy Pop	N	N
218	Primary Colours	The Horrors
219	All Mod Cons	The Jam	N	N
220	Alligator	The National
221	Broken English	Marianne Faithful	N	N
222	Fever Ray	Fever Ray
223	Neon Bible	Arcade Fire
224	Heaven Up Here	Echo and the Bunnymen	N	N
225	Electric Warrior	T. Rex	N	N
226	The Doors	The Doors	N	N
227	Imagine	John Lennon	N	N
228	Brighten the Corners	Pavement	N	N
229	Metal Box	Public Image Ltd	N	N
230	Aladdin Sane	David Bowie	N(Y)	N
231	The Chronic	Dr. Dre	N	N
232	Songs of Leonard Cohen	Leonard Cohen	N	N(Y)
233	Down in Albion	Babyshambles
234	Behaviour	Pet Shop Boys	N	N
235	Murder Ballads	Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds	N	N(Y)
236	Suicide	Suicide	N	Y
237	The xx	The xx
238	Show Your Bones	Yeah Yeah Yeahs
239	Boy in Da Corner	Dizzee Rascal
240	New Boots and Panties!!	Ian Dury	N	N
241	Ray of Light	Madonna
242	Off the Wall	Michael Jackson	N	N
243	The Hissing of Summer Lawns	Joni Mitchell	N	N
244	Smother	Wild Beasts
245	Fuzzy Logic	Super Furry Animals
246	MTV Unplugged in New York	Nirvana	N(Y)	N
247	Glasvegas	Glasvegas
248	The Slim Shady LP	Eminem	N	N
249	The Fat of the Land	Prodigy	N	N
250	Weezer	Weezer	N	N
251	Surf’s Up	The Beach Boys	N(Y)	Y
252	Visions	Grimes
253	Exile on Main Street	Pussy Galore
254	Meat is Murder	The Smiths	N	N(Y)
255	The English Riviera	Metronomy
256	This Year’s Model	Elvis Costello and the Attractions	Y	N
257	The Boatman’s Call	Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds	N	Y
258	Five Leaves Left	Nick Drake	N	N
259	Yo! Bum Rush the Show	Public Enemy	N(Y)	N(Y)
260	The Specials	The Specials	N	N
261	Live!	Bob Marley and the Wailers	N	N
262	Criminal Minded	Boogie Down Productions	N	N
263	I Speak Because I Can	Laura Marling
264	Please Please Me	The Beatles	N	N(Y)
265	Celebrity Skin	Hole	N	N
266	A Rush of Blood to the Head	Coldplay
267	Stupidity	Dr. Feelgood	N	N
268	Todd	Todd Rundgren	N	N
269	Skying	The Horrors	N	N
270	The Kinks Are the Village Green Preservation Society	The Kinks	N	Y
271	Loaded	The Velvet Underground	N(Y)	N(Y)
272	Parachutes	Coldplay
273	The College Dropout	Kanye West
274	Green	R.E.M.	N	Y
275	Quadrophenia	The Who	N(Y)	N(Y)
276	Ocean Rain	Echo and the Bunnymen	N	N
277	Reading, Writing and Arithmetic	The Sundays	N	N
278	Cut	The Slits	N	N
279	Trout Mask Replica	Captain Beefheart and his Magic Band	Y	Y
280	Drukqs	Aphex Twin	N	N
281	My Aim is True	Elvis Costello	N(Y)	N
282	Grand Prix	Teenage Fanclub	N	N
283	Roxy Music	Roxy Music	Y	N
284	13 Songs	Fugazi	N	N
285	Midnight Love	Marvin Gaye	N	N
286	Dust	Screaming Trees	N	N
287	Reign in Blood	Slayer	N	N
288	Music of My Mind	Stevie Wonder	N	N
289	The Modern Lovers	The Modern Lovers	Y	N
290	Expecting to Fly	The Bluetones
291	Younger than Yesterday	The Byrds	N(Y)	N(Y)
292	The New Fellas	The Cribs
293	High Land, Hard Rain	Aztec Camera	N	N
294	Myths of the Near Future	Klaxons
295	Doggystyle	Snoop Doggy Dogg	N	N
296	Let’s Dance	David Bowie	N(Y)	N
297	Ege Bamyasi	Can	Y	N(Y)
298	Malcom McLaren	Malcolm McLaren	N	N
299	16 Lovers Lane	The Go-Betweens	N	N
300	The Who By Numbers	The Who	N(Y)	N(Y)
301	World of Echo	Arthur Russell	N	N
302	Homework	Daft Punk	N	N
303	Mingus Ah Um	Charles Mingus	N(Y)	N(Y)
304	UFOrb	The Orb	N	N
305	Every Picture Tells a Story	Rod Stewart	N	N
306	The Freewheeling Bob Dylan	Bob Dylan	N	N(Y)
307	Midnight Vultures	Beck	N	N
308	It’s a Shame About Ray	Lemonheads	N	N
309	Metallica	Metallica	N	N
310	Countdown to Ecstasy	Steely Dan	N(Y)	N
311	Guerilla	Super Furry Animals		N
312	Treasure	Cocteau Twins	N	N
313	Frank’s Wild Years	Tom Waits	N	N
314	Spiderland	Slint	N	N
315	Cheap Thrills	Big Brother and the Holding Company	N	N
316	Imperial Bedroom	Elvis Costello and the Attractions	N(Y)	N
317	Grievous Angel	Gram Parsons	N	N
318	OG Original Gangster	Ice-T	N	N
319	Who’s Next	The Who	N(Y)	N(Y)
320	Swordfishtrombones	Tom Waits	N	N
321	Lost Souls	Doves
322	This is Happening	LCD Soundsystem
323	Bitches Brew	Miles Davis	N(Y)	N(Y)
324	Life’s Rich Pageant	R.E.M.	N	N(Y)
325	Sea Change	Beck	N	N
326	I Can Hear the Heart Beating As One	Yo La Tengo	N	N
327	Mutations	Beck	N	N
328	Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots	The Flaming Lips	N	N
329	Heroes	David Bowie	N(Y)	N
330	Third	Portishead
331	Kick out the Jams	MC5	N(Y)	N(Y)
332	HMS Fable	Shack
333	Band on the Run	Paul McCartney and Wings	N	N
334	Since I Left You	The Avalanches
335	…Like Clockwork	Queens of the Stone Age	N	N
336	Raw Like Sushi	Neneh Cherry	N	N
337	The Grey Album	Danger Mouse
338	Ready to Die	Notorious BIG	N	N
339	Ten	Pearl Jam	N	N
340	We Are Family	Sister Sledge	N	N
341	Closing Time	Tom Waits	N	N
342	Lazer Guided Melodies	Spritualized	N	N
343	John Wesley Harding	Bob Dylan	N	N(Y)
344	Beautiful Freak	Eels	N	N
345	Punch the Clock	Elvis Costello	N(Y)	N
346	Low Life	New Order	N	N
347	Dirty	Sonic Youth	N(Y)	N(Y)
348	Whitney	Whitney Houston	N	N
349	An Awesome Wave	Alt-J
350	BRMC	Black Rebel Motorcycle Club	N	N
351	Sweetheart of the Rodeo	The Byrds	N(Y)	N(Y)
352	White Light/White Heat	The Velvet Underground	Y	N(Y)
353	Mclusky Do Dallas	Mclusky
354	Hot Buttered Soul	Isaac Hayes	Y	N
355	New York Dolls	New York Dolls	Y	N
356	Bossanova	Pixies	N	N
357	Copper Blue	Sugar	N	N
358	Rock Bottom	Robert Wyatt	N	N
359	We’re Only in It for the Money	The Mothers of Invention	N(Y)	N
360	Room on Fire	The Strokes
361	A Nod is as Good as a Wink	The Faces	N	N
362	Hello Nasty	Beastie Boys	N	N
363	Damaged	Black Flag	Y	N
364	For Emma, Forever Ago	Bon Iver
365	Fresh Fruit for Rotting Vegatables	Dead Kennedys	N	N
366	Songs of Love and Hate	Leonard Cohen	N	Y
367	Nights Out	Metronomy
368	Hail to the Thief	Radiohead
369	Strange Mercy	St. Vincent
370	Men’s Needs, Women’s Needs, Whatever	The Cribs
371	Odelay	Beck	N	N
372	Atomizer	Big Black	N	N
373	There’s No Place Like America Today	Curtis Mayfield	N	N
374	In the Wee Small Hours	Frank Sinatra	N	N
375	Vauxhall and I	Morrissey	N	N
376	Live at the Harlem Square Club	Sam Cooke	N	N
377	Stormcock	Roy Harper	N	N
378	Pink Flag	Wire	Y	N
379	The Boy with the Arab Strap	Belle and Sebastian	N	N(Y)
380	Silent Alarm	Bloc Party	N	N
381	Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps)	David Bowie	Y	N
382	Bridge over Troubled Water	Simon and Garfunkel	N	N
383	Someone To Drive You Home	The Long Blondes
384	Elvis Presley	Elvis Presley	Y	Y
385	Get Behind Me Satan	The White Stripes
386	Revival	Gillian Welch	N	N
387	Combat Rock	The Clash	N(Y)	N
388	Happy Sad	Tim Buckley	N(Y)	N(Y)
389	Le Tigre	Le Tigre	N	N
390	A Northern Soul	The Verve	N	N
391	Burial	Burial
392	Beauty and the Beat	Edan
393	Dirty Mind	Prince	N	N
394	Chairs Missing	Wire	N(Y)	N
395	De Stijl	The White Stripes	N	N
396	L.A.M.F.	Heartbreakers	Y	N
397	Reasonable Doubt	Jay-Z	N	N
398	Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere	Neil Young	N(Y)	N(Y)
399	The Lyre of Orpheus/Abattoir Blues	Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds	N	N(Y)
400	This Nation’s Saving Grace	The Fall	N	N
401	20 Jazz Funk Greats	Throbbing Gristle	N	N(Y)
402	Twenty One	Mystery Jets
403	Vespertine	Björk	N	N
404	No Other	Gene Clark	N	N
405	Otis Blue	Otis Redding	N	N
406	Rated R	Queens of the Stone Age	N	N
407	Going Blank Again	Ride	N	N
408	Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain	Pavement	N	N
409	Tago Mago	Can	N(Y)	N(Y)
410	Antics	Interpol	N	N
411	Madvillainy	Madvillain
412	Endtroducing…	DJ Shadow	N	N
413	Pills N Thrills and Bellyaches	Happy Mondays	N	N
414	Dig Your Own Hole	The Chemical Brothers	N	N
415	Chet Baker Sings	Chet Baker
416	Merriweather Post Pavillion	Animal Collective
417	1977	Ash	N	N
418	Electro-Shock Blues	Eels
419	Let It Come Down	Spiritualized	N	N
420	People’s Instinctive Travels…	A Tribe Called Quest	N	N
421	Radio City	Big Star	Y	N(Y)
422	Too-Rye-Ay	Dexys Midnight Runners	N	N
423	Live at Leeds	The Who	N(Y)	N(Y)
424	The Joshua Tree	U2	N	N
425	Nancy and Lee	Nancy Sinatra and Lee Hazelwood	N	N
426	Goo	Sonic Youth	N(Y)	N(Y)
427	Here Come the Warm Jets	Brian Eno	N	N(Y)
428	Born in the USA	Bruce Springsteen	N	N(Y)
429	Bleed America	Jimmy Eat World
430	Scott 4	Scott Walker	N	N(Y)
431	Badmotorfinger	Soundgarden	N	N
432	Tindersticks	Tindersticks	N	N
433	2001	Dr. Dre	N	N
434	Steve McQueen	Prefab Sprout	N	N
435	Easter	Patti Smith	N(Y)	N(Y)
436	Mirrored	Battles
437	Dear Science	TV on the Radio
438	Aha Shake Heartbreak	Kings of Leon
439	The Futureheads	The Futureheads	N	N
440	Life’s a Riot with Spy vs. Spy	Billy Bragg	N	N
441	Arrival	ABBA	N	N
442	Al Green is Love	Al Green	N	N
443	Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle	Bill Callahan
444	Violator	Depeche Mode	N	N
445	Tusk	Fleetwood Mac	N	N
446	The Warning	Hot Chip
447	Diamond Dogs	David Bowie	N(Y)	N
448	Sci-Fi Lullabies	Suede	N	N
449	AM	Arctic Monkeys
450	Rid of Me	PJ Harvey	N	N
451	Third/Sister Lovers	Big Star	N(Y)	Y
452	The B-52s	The B-52s	N	N
453	The House of Love	The House of Love	N	N
454	The Writing on the Wall	Destiny’s Child	N	N
455	Vampire Weekend	Vampire Weekend
456	September of My Years	Frank Sinatra	N	N
457	Black Cherry	Goldfrapp
458	Yankee Hotel Foxtrot	Wilco	N	N
459	The Black Album	Jay-Z	N	N
460	Bleach	Nirvana	Y	N
461	Generation Terrorists	Manic Street Preachers	N	N
462	Master of Puppets	Metallica	N	N
463	Pod	The Breeders	N	N
464	Because of the Times	Kings of Leon
465	High Violet	The National
466	The W	Wu-Tang Clan	N	N
467	The Idiot	Iggy Pop	N	N
468	Chutes Too Narrow	The Shins	N	N
469	Holland	The Beach Boys	N(Y)	N(Y)
470	Graduation	Kanye West
471	Oracular Spectacular	MGMT
472	Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness	Smashing Pumpkins	N	N
473	A Storm in Heaven	The Verve	N	N
474	Tarot Sport	Fuck Buttons	N	N
475	Smoke Ring for My Halo	Kurt Vile
476	Foo Fighters	Foo Fighters	N	N
477	Crystal Castles	Crystal Castles
478	Trouble Will Find Me	The National
479	The Real Ramona	Throwing Muses	N	N
480	I Never Loved a Man the Way I Love You	Aretha Franklin	N	N
481	Smile	Brian Wilson
482	Lady in Satin	Billie Holiday		N
483	Blood and Chocolate	Elvis Costello and the Attractions	N	N
484	The River	Bruce Springsteen	N	N(Y)
485	Good Kid, M.A.A.D City	Kendrick Lamar
486	Homogenic	Björk	N	N
487	Sound Affects	The Jam	N	N
488	I’m Your Man	Leonard Cohen	N	N(Y)
489	George Best	The Wedding Present	N	N
490	Back in the USA	MC5	Y	Y
491	Actually	Pet Shop Boys	N	N
492	Hidden	These New Puritans
493	Blood	This Mortal Coil	N	N
494	The Head on the Door	The Cure	N	N
495	Hot Fuss	The Killers
496	Album	Girls
497	Random Access Memories	Daft Punk
498	Berlin	Lou Reed	N	N(Y)
499	Star	Belly	N	N
500	Stankonia	OutKast	N	N

What struck me when I compared this list with Joe S. Harrington’s from 2001 on Blastitude and the Rolling Stone list from 2003 is that the number of albums from Harrington’s list in this New Musical Express list is only one less than in Rolling Stone’s list (I haven’t checked agreement).

What this suggests to me is that New Musical Express, regarded in the past as less of a promoter of “popular” rock than Rolling Stone or Spin, is today no different from them. Writers like “janitor-x” have said that such magazines should ignore music that does not resemble 1960s music, like 1980s Metallica, Slayer, the Dead Kennedys and Black Flag, but this is hardly in evidence.

More than this, and probably more than with the Rolling Stone list, there is little consistency of any sort in the New Musical Express list, noted from when the Beatles’ Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band was at #87 instead of being at #1.

The treatment of the most famous “popular” singers and bands since the “punk revolution” is not consistent either: if Whitney Houston gets one album, should not all the popular “easy listening” singers since then do so??

More than that, those who have studied music for as long as I have – which dates back to my discovery of Harrington’s list by an accident on Google in 2001 – are so aware of the large number of omitted artists that I have decided to compile a list below of twenty omitted artists from the writings of Harrington, David Keenan and Piero Scaruffi. Whilst I am in no way certain that these are the twenty most deserving omitted artists, they would certainly change the list quite dramatically if added.

A Representative Album by Twenty Artists Recommended by Two or More of Scaruffi, Harrington and/or Keenan and not on NME list
Album	Artist	Notes
Free Jazz	Ornette Coleman	Aside from Davis, Coltrane and Mingus, these three were the giants of avant-garde and free jazz during the period it was the underground music
Spiritual Unity	Albert Ayler
Atlantis	Sun Ra
The Hangman’s Beautiful Daughter	The Incredible String Band	Either adored or hated by most; NME omission understandable given the magazine’s history as a promoter of punk music.
Live Dead	The Grateful Dead
Easter Everywhere	Thirteenth Floor Elevators
The Parable of Arable Land	The Red Krayola	Regarded by some as more experimental and eccentric than Beefheart; have heard but cannot agree fully.
In the Court of the Crimson King	King Crimson	Regarded frequently as the first and best progressive rock album; though progressive rock is generally disliked at NME.
The Marble Index	Nico
Master of Reality	Black Sabbath	Originally reviled, latterly revered and amazingly ignored by NME.
Faust IV	Faust
Tyranny and Mutation	Blue Öyster Cult	Arguable the first pop metal band, often ignored by critics.
The Dictators Go Girl Crazy	The Dictators
Wild Gift	X	Critically revered post-punk band
Ace of Spades	Motörhead	Cited as the precursor to Metallica by that band, yet ignored by NME and many others.
Minor Threat	Minor Threat
Double Nickels on the Dime	The Minutemen	Among most critically beloved bands of 1980s, but never dented Billboard Top 200
Charmed Life	Half Japanese
Twin Infinitives	Royal Trux	Acclaimed avant-garde band of 1990s
Slow, Deep and Hard	Type O Negative	Frontman Pete Steele died in 2010; band known for its gothic metal style with humorous but dark themes